Hiring Mike Sullivan as coach most impactful Rangers move in offseason: poll
The New York Rangers have done their fair share of retooling after missing the Stanley Cup Playoffs last season. Though the Rangers made several important changes to the roster this offseason, it’s the one behind the bench that their fans believe to be the most impactful.
In a recent Forever Blueshirts poll, fans overwhelmingly identified the hiring of coach Mike Sullivan as the Rangers most important offseason move. The decision wasn’t close — the Sullivan hire received 59.8 percent of the vote, far outpacing the other options: trading K’Andre Miller and Chris Kreider (19.65 percent), signing Vladislav Gavrikov (11.6 percent), and re-signing Will Cuylle (8.9 percent).
Perhaps most surprising is that signing Gavrikov, New York’s top free-agent target, to a seven-year, $49 million contract didn’t finish higher on this list. The 29-year-old is exactly what the Rangers needed to stabilize their blue line and was the best defenseman on the market.
Perhaps fans believed that trading Kreider and Miller was more important because it freed up substantial salary-cap space in order to sign Gavrikov and Cuylle (and several other depth players). Without those trades, the hands of general manager Chris Drury were largely tied.
But in the end, it was more about the new coach and not new or departed players, per our poll results.
Mike Sullivan hire more than coaching change for Rangers
The hiring of Sullivan shifts the narrative and reshapes the organizations expectations. For a franchise that’s spent decades trying to get over the hump, this feels like and important step and reset.
Rangers fans have seen coaches come and go — each with a different message, system, and style of play. But Sullivan brings something none of the recent coaches couldn’t offer: a decade of success and back-to-back Stanley Cup championships. Peter Laviolette won the Cup with the Carolina Hurricanes in 2006, but Sullivan’s run in Pittsburgh makes him the most successful head coach the Rangers have hired in years. He’s proven at the highest level, and is someone Drury has always had his eyes on since he became Rangers general manager in 2021.
The search for the right fit enters a new chapter
Sullivan is New York’s fourth coach since Alain Vigneault’s exit in 2018. David Quinn, Gerard Gallant, and Laviolette weren’t able to deliver lasting identities in New York, forcing the team to restart over and over again.
That churn takes a toll. Schemes change, styles shift, and messages get lost. What the Rangers needed isn’t just a new coach — they needed a coach who the players know is here for the long term. Right or wrong, this core group of players has the reputation as “coach killer.”
That ends with the hiring of Sullivan, whom Drury chased for years to coach this team. A decade in Pittsburgh, two Stanley Cup championships, and nearly 500 wins. He’s not here to grow into the job, he already knows what it takes. And he has the complete backing of his boss, Drury.
One of Sullivan’s first moves was to convince Quinn, the very coach Drury fired in his first move as GM four years ago, to return to the organization in a supporting role. That decision shows Sullivan values connections, and he’s concerned with results rather than optics. It also shows the power he has already within the organization.
A track record that speaks for itself
It’s easy to see why the fans are excited about the Sullivan hiring. Not that Laviolette and Gallant, the previous two coaches, didn’t have impressive resumes, but there’s something about “Sully” that makes him stand out. Sure, the 2 rings are a big part of that. But his commanding presence likely appeals to the Blueshirt Faithful, especially coming off that trainwreck of a season in 2024-25.
In this case, familiarity is a good thing, too. Rangers fans have seen Sullivan’s work up close — first as an assistant under John Tortorella during a successful run on Broadway more than a decade ago, and then the past 10 years with a division rival.
Even though the Penguins failed to make the playoffs the past three seasons, Sullivan’s earned enough good will to have the full support, not only of Drury, but the Rangers fan base.
His experience goes beyond the NHL level. Sullivan recently coached the United States to a second-place finish at the 2025 Four Nations Face-Off and is set to coach the Americans at the 2026 Milano Cortina Olympics. Before that, he served as head coach of the 2007 U.S. Men’s National Team and held assistant roles for Team USA in 2006, 2008, and 2017.
Add in his time as head coach in Boston and stints as an assistant in Vancouver, Tampa, Chicago, and New York, and Sullivan brings over 20 years of NHL coaching experience into a Rangers locker room that’s been desperate for a sense of direction and accountability.
Yes, there’s a lot to like. And the fans made it clear in our poll where they stand on the most important move of this offseason.
