Buchnevich back versus Isles, but why sit him at all?

Buchnevich (Mandatory Credit: Robert Mayer-USA TODAY Sports)

During this season New York Rangers head coach, Alain Vigneault has experienced endless scrutiny. The most criticized aspect has been his management of the lineup. The fan base have crushed him for defensive pairings and line adjustments.

NYR fans have a strong infatuation with some players and hatred for others. Fans defend players like Kevin Shattenkirk when the coach calls him “A work in progress”; even though that is exactly what he is. Meanwhile a player like David Desharnais was ridiculed early in the year.

The one player fans are in love with the most is Pavel Buchnevich. Buch is an offensive talent and a threat to score almost every game. Many believe he is a product of an AV vendetta. This allows Buch to skate by (pun intended) with lackluster play. Buchnevich is a top line talent, that doesn’t make him a top line player though.

140 Feet Short

There are two factors that come into play with Buchnevich. First, he is an international prospect. There for his game and play style got recognition for lighting the lamp via shot or pass. Second, he is only in his second year in the NHL and is 22 years old. He is young and will take time to get his game where it needs to be. It’s a scary thought to say he needs to grow as a NHL level player, when he is the third best point getter on the team.

Nevertheless, he will need to grow. I find Alain Vigneault to be a confusing head coach. He inherited a defense minded team and now it is more offensive. Yet there are things that have changed, for instance Rick Nash was not a penalty killer before AV got here but he is now. A player like Mats Zuccarello has thrived in a two way forward role. It seems that AV wants Buch to provide a full game.

There is not a dislike because of age, a player like Jimmy Vesey, has gotten quite the look because his game has improved quite a bit since last season. Vesey has been strong on both ends of the ice and thus has been rewarded with ice time.

Buchnevich getting sat against the Vegas Golden Knights stemmed directly from his off being off against the Arizona Coyotes. The only reason to be upset as a fan is due to the recent scoring drought. The top third scorer on the bench during a scoring drought? Doesn’t make much sense right? Except honestly Buchnevich just hasn’t been producing as of late, three points in the last 10 games for the youngster won’t cut it. As a matter of fact in the last 20 games Buch has had ONE multipoint game, and had 13 scoreless games in that span.

If Buchnevich is lighting the lamp non stop and gets sat then fans have a reason to gripe. Three points in ten games is not enough to make up for the deficiency on the back end for Buchnevich.

Buch-y Over-time Challenge

Hate AV all you want but Buchnevich is not a player that helps his case with his play sometimes. I liken him to Marian Gaborik, offensive talent but there’s a reason why Gaborik was expendable for both the Rangers and Blue Jackets.

To simply put it Buchnevich would tear it up in a role like Phil Kessel. If AV could say “go skate around and score” Buch would be able to take more chances and make more plays. Unfortunately that isn’t how the Rangers are set up, not this roster and not for the foreseeable future. Buchnevich will either have to adapt his game to a 65-35 (Offense-defense) game or he will become expendable.

Over time (see what I did there) Buch will need to grow as a hockey player not just an offensive player. If he does that then he no longer is the player that gets scratched. The team needs him down the stretch to learn a full game and learn it fast. His game and his effort will decide if he plays or sits going forward.

Share: